*if you want the quick answer, skip to the bottom
WORLD CUP YEAR! Every four years (since 1999), South African sports fans get excited for the Rugby and Cricket extravaganzas. YES 1999, the year we tied with Australia in both semi-finals, but went home. I know we all blame Donald for not running, everyone has forgotten that he took 4/32 in 10 overs and should never have been batting chasing what now looks like a T20 score (213). If anyone gets some deserved finger pointing it’s a certain DJ Cullinan, who scored 6 off 30 balls, and then ran himself out. What people do remember is that Zulu carried us that tournament, coming in at #8 and klapping it, and even had Bouch batting at 9. He was player of the tournament, an award he really didn’t want after the drama and disappointment. If you’re a masochist, watch this one:
I could go on, but many more much talented people have written about this game before me, but it does bring me to the main point:
We just don’t have enough batting, and we are now exactly 4 months away from the opening game against England on May 30th. Having a look at the current squad, and who has been in Ottis’ plans for the past 12 months.
Here is who I think he is going to pick for his side/squad of 15 players
Q de Kock [H Klaasen]
HE van der Dussen [RR Hendricks/ A Markram]
HM Amla
F du Plessis
DA Miller
JP Duminy
AL Phehlukwayo
K Rabada
DW Steyn
Imran Tahir [T Shamzi]
L Ngidi [D Olivier/D Pretorius/ W Mulder/ B Hendricks/ D Paterson/ A Nortje/ C Morris]
(it’s not that different to the guys we took to England 2 years ago, we bombed out of that mini tournament winning 1 out of 3 league games, incase you’ve forgotten Pakistan won)
I don’t see a way to take vd Dussen, Reeza and Markram, as that would drop the last bowler slot which is the most contested one.
We have to take both spinners to England. The ICC are now in control of the pitches this time around. That is codeword for India getting conditions to suit them, we will need spin.
Both JPD and Ngidi are currently injured, with Wian Mulder/ Chris Morris recently returned and Anrich Nortje also doubtful as he is a long term layoff. What confuses me a bit is that they have been playing most of their strongest 11 and the guys on the fringe are getting very few chances to impress. We will see if the Sri Lanka series
In terms of batting, the only other guys who have played in the past 12 months are, Markram (15 games, average 22, top score 44). K Zondo, C Jonker and D Elgar. none of them are currently in the squad so must be out of the running.
In terms of bowlers who can bat, our tail is really long. We would be looking at Rabada at 8, Steyn at 9. The days of someone like Pollock coming in at 10 are a distant memory. This makes Andile Pehlukwayo an almost definite starter – while he has taken 25 wickets @ 23 and scored 200+ runs @ 32, I just don’t see him as a classic #7 (he is just 22 years old, so is still probably improving).
This tail, from 8-11 averages 16+9+8+?? (lungi ngidi’s odi batting average is 34, he’s batted 6 times with 5 not outs – I’d expect 5-10 from him) – 38 runs
Let’s compare this with England tail from the ODI series in England v India last July
Lilley,Plunkett, Rashid, Wood – 18,20,20,8 – 64 runs
So it’s obvious the top order batsmen need to get runs. I don’t really see Klaasen and QdK both playing in the same lineup unless we get a batsman in poor form, but imagine how bad things would be if we didn’t have a ‘keeper with an ODI average of 43 at a strike rate of 94?! What would it look like if we played an extra batsman at 7, with Phehlukwayo at 8 and Steyn/Ngidi being dropped. We would then need JPD to bowl all 10 overs then. Our ODI strength has always been decent allrounders, and I really wonder why Dwaine Pretorius has not been backed along with Phehlukwayo – he has a domestic record of 33 with the bat and 24 with the ball – that is comparable with anything pollock, Klusener, Kallis did and way better than Phehl 22/28 with the bat/ball. Yet he’s been given just 3 games in the past 12 months and faced just 33 balls.
The other big and related issue, the batsmen we have can’t bowl. Amla, Faf, Miller, VdDussen never bowl. Reeza Hendricks might have taken a wicket the other night, but in 149 domestic 50over games he’s bowled a grand total of 192 balls. You don’t give a guy like that the ball in a world cup. We learnt that obvious lesson in 2015 when ABDv decided he was a bowler all of a sudden and chose to bowl death overs in a world cup semi. People will remember that loss for the Behardien dropped catch, the Philander/Abbot selection issue but him bowling pies at the end was just as bad.
So to be honest, it doesn’t look good. we need:
*Top order to fire, there’s probably very few runs coming from the tail
*JPD to get fit and regain form with bat and ball
*Bowlers all to pitch in, there’s no overs coming from bits and pieces players.
Looking at the ICC rankings we have
Faf and QdK in 7th and 10th
Rabada in 4th, Tahir 11th, Phehl 33
no one in the top 10 allrounders
We’re ranked 4th in the world,
The betting has England 3/1, India 4/1, Aus 6/1 and us 8/1.
It would be a nice surprise if we could not dominate the league part of the world cup for once, scrape into the semis and then play 2 decent games to win it. The format has changed, it’s now 10 teams in a single round robin. The top 4 go through to semi-finals. You’d basically need to win 6/7 of those games to get through. It’s possible, I just don’t see it happening.
*quick answer – our bowlers can’t bat, our batters can’t bowl